MMRA Domain Station location assessment – More Spin
MMRA Called for alternate submissions 2 very viable submissions were offered.
What a one sided report this is, we assume it was all done in house.
As far as we can find out no independent opinions were sought.
It makes no mention of Improved traffic outcomes.
Less disruption to residents.
Less damage to St Kilda Road.
South African War Memorial saved.
Domain tram interchange saved.
Many trees saved.
This is what their one sided report came up with, no mention of the loss of over 200 trees, trashing the heritage value.
Five years of noise and disruption to 8000 residents. Years of traffic chaos.
The spin starts here. If you believe in fairy tails this propaganda is for you, no downside at all in their plan .
MMRA has ruled out an option to relocate the station into the southern edge of the Shrine of Remembrance Grounds adjacent to St Kilda Road.
The preferred station location at Domain is the result of detailed investigations, design and planning by engineers, transport modellers and other experts with experience on rail tunnels and other infrastructure projects in Australia and around the world.
Works will be staged and St Kilda Road temporarily reconfigured for up to three years to enable trams, vehicles and cyclists to keep moving until the full road surface can be reinstated. See the Construction plans page for more details.
In line with the approach to date, efforts are continuing by MMRA and the project’s shortlisted bidders to further minimise temporary impacts on traffic, trees and the amenity of the precinct during construction of the new underground station.
Works in St Kilda Road and the Albert Road Reserve will be undertaken in accordance with permit conditions set by Heritage Victoria.
In addition a $25 million package of road enhancement works across the project will help offset the impacts of temporary disruptions to the road network.
Domain Station under St Kilda Road will:
- Give one of Melbourne’s most prominent business, education and tourist precincts its first ever train station, with almost 40,000 people set to use it daily by 2031.
- Enhance access to around 33,000 jobs in the precinct, and service 17,000 residents living within 800 metres of the location by 2031.
- Provide a pedestrian walkway under busy St Kilda Road to greatly enhance road and pedestrian safety and accessibility.
- Be constructed in a way that provides an effective and controlled engineering solution for the local ground conditions.
- Provide a seamless and fast train-tram interchange that significantly relieves pressure on crowded tram services on the St Kilda Road-Swanston Street corridor, the world’s busiest tram route. More than 50% of passengers passing through Domain Station will use it as an interchange between trains and trams.
- Have minimal impact on the Shrine of Remembrance and its Grounds.
A Domain Station in the Shrine of Remembrance Grounds was dismissed because it will:
- Significantly impact the Shrine of Remembrance and its Grounds.
- Cost more (around $100 million) and deliver fewer long-term transport benefits.
- Add at least three minutes travel time to the journey of thousands of passengers in each direction every day who use the train-tram interchange (from tram stop to platform), undermining one of the key long-term public transport outcomes for Melbourne.
- Create heritage impacts associated with the removal of the Macpherson Robertson Fountain, the Remembrance Garden Memorial and Cobbers Statue.
- Extensively impact the Shrine’s heritage value by requiring the removal of up to 136 trees in the Shrine Grounds, 60 of which are memorial trees with plaques dedicated to service units.
- Require the removal of an extra 50,000 cubic metres of material, meaning more truck movements and higher project costs.
- Still require temporary lane closures on St Kilda Road to build the pedestrian underpass and new tram interchange.
- Disruption during construction to more than 160 events held annually at the Shrine of Remembrance and within its Grounds.
- Require further approvals, thereby delaying project delivery.
- Create permanent visual impacts on the Shrine Grounds due to extra station infrastructure.